Judges Engineered Willie’s Predicament

Judges in Willie Manning’s case engineered their DNA test refusal by considering only damning prosecution evidence, departing from practice in other cases. Prosecution evidence is by its nature unlikely to be anything other than damning: in any legal case an assessment of guilt will be exaggerated if based on prosecution evidence alone, without the leavening of the counter arguments of the defense.  In Willie’s case the contrast between the two methods of review is stark: the ‘prosecution evidence only’ method establishes ‘conclusive and overwhelming guilt’, but the ‘complete record’ method establishes… absolutely nothing. Every point made by the State is discredited by the defense; and the State’s witnesses are found to be criminals who were given huge favors, of which the jury was not told. Yet the 5 judges chose to use the ‘prosecution evidence only’ method, with its inevitably damning conclusion.

The 4 judges who supported Willie’s request for DNA testing did use the normal ‘complete review’ method, with the result that they came to conclusions such as, “Manning presented evidence at court that undermined the court’s case against him”. Moreover, in previous cases, such as that of the exonerated death row inmate, Kennedy Brewer, the usual ‘complete record’ method has been used, leading to DNA testing being granted.

Accountability is everywhere these days: endless forms are completed every day throughout the world to ensure that correct procedures have been followed. But it would seem that in the USA a man’s death can hang in the balance without anyone questioning whether correct procedures have even been defined, yet alone followed.

5 judges in Mississippi have knowingly created conditions that are likely to result in Willie’s death. Why they have done this we cannot know, but it is certainly shocking and very serious. If Governor Bryant will not stop this execution, President Obama should.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in African American, Ain't you got a right to the tree of life, America, Brookville Gardens murders, capital murder, Clive Stafford Smith, convicted, conviction, date, Death, death penalty, death penalty injustice, Death Row, Death Row Injustice, death row injustice mississippi, Death Row injustice,, denied effective counsel, DNA testing, double murders, Exculpatory evidence, execution, Execution Date Opposed, execution date opposed, failed to disclose exculpatory evidence, fingerprints, Fly Manning, Ineffective trial attorneys, Injustice, Innocent, jailhouse informant, Jim Hood Attorney General, Jon Steckler, Jon Steckler and Tiffany Miller, Justice, justice, Justice for WIllie Manning, justice for Willie Manning, Justice4Willie, Manning, missed deadline, Mississippi, Mississippi State, Mississippi State Penitentiary, Mississippi State Penitentiary Parchman, MS, murder victims' relatives, murders, NAACP, no physical evidence, North America, Oktibbeha County, opposed, Parchman, Penalty phase, Penitentiary, petition, Post, prosecutors presented false evidence, prosecutors withheld evidence, Reprieve, Row, stacked jury, Supreme Court, Suzanne Steckler, Tiffany Miller, tree of life, tree of life video, tree of life,, Uncategorized, United States of America, unreliable witnesses, USA, victims' relatives, Vilification, Willie, Willie Fly Manning, Willie Jerome Manning, Willie Jerome Manning Mississippi, Willie Jerome Manning Mississippi Death Row, Willie Manning, Willie Manning Mississippi, Willie Manning Mississippi Death Row, Willie Manning murderer, Willie Manning murders, Willie Manning video and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.